October 22, 2019


The Act of Giving It Your Attention


Start today by reading this, which comes from the Head of School at Wooster:

[S]creens and the internet are causing us all to slowly lose the ability to do what is called “deep reading.” In the meantime, I’m going to keep asking you all to give me your attention in this way: Reading deeply, and then thinking deeply and reflecting. Questions are a part of the process too, and I am happy to answer them at any time. Even if you don’t agree with the content, or it makes you slightly uncomfortable, just the act of giving it your attention, and thinking deeply about it, is good for your brain. In this age of distraction and sound bites, it gives me great joy to help our community members retain and strengthen the gift of deeper reading.

Like our own discussion of online reading, what this doesn’t say is as important as what it does say. We’ve known for a long time now that the Internet is shallowing our brains — Nicholas Carr’s The Shallows is one of the best journalistic books on the subject — but that is a problem with how we use the Internet, not the Internet itself.

We all need help “retain[ing] and strengthen[ing] the gift of deeper reading.” It’s a habit you can only build over time, but it’s as Matt Byrnes says here: “[J]ust the act of giving it your attention, and thinking deeply about it, is good for your brain.”

This is why I write to you instructionally. Put simply, it’s good for your brain to read this sort of thing, even if it makes you uncomfortable.

Today, your reading is a soft reboot of the makerspace itself:

What Is a (Humanities) Makerspace?

Walk yourself through the entire post. Plug in to watch the video. Skim attached articles. At this point, you’ve been in the space long enough to experience the practical application of these ideas, so you should also consider your own work.

This “deep reading” will contextualize today’s assignment, too. You have reached another inflection point for grade abatement profiling, which means another moment to self-assess, collaborate, and recommit to the work of the space.

Remember that this kind of assessment also requires you to read deeply, to consider uncomfortable truths, to question, etc., in order to think deeply and reflect accurately on your progress. As necessary, you would use the links in the “Essentials Pack” for assessment, which is available in several places online and in class:

Clarifying Grade Abatement
Grade Abatement Profiles
Universal Skills and Traits
Step-By-Step Guide to Assessment
WIP GAP Scores Explained
2019-2020 Calendar of Assessment
2019-2020 Student GAP Reports

The assignment itself is on Google Classroom. The form provides you ample opportunity for honest self-assessment, since it links repeatedly to these other “deep dives” into your learning.

For today, this work is about you, the individual, taking on the sometimes uncomfortable task of deep reading. It’s also about you, the individual, completing the often uncomfortable task of self-assessment.

Plug in, focus, and work. Ask questions in person, but also ask them here, or through email. When in doubt, just ask. Use your voice to be part of the discussion.

Note: The deadline for your GAP reports will be extended to tomorrow to give you time for this. We will still distribute your next novel tomorrow.

Ongoing Discussion: Grade Abatement Profiles

This post is reserved for discussion of the profiles, skills, and traits that are used to direct and to assess your learning. Whether through the opening-day orientation for all courses, your individual course syllabus, or more recent explanations of grade abatement, you’ve seen these GAP staples a dozen times. They are the most important facet of this learning environment. When we assess your body of work for a GAP score, the protocol depends entirely on your fluency in what each profile argues and how each pair of skills and traits connect.


Grade Abatement Profiles, Skills, and Traits


Read the following handout carefully, whether for the first time or the hundredth time. Unpack every word, phrase, and sentence. Then enter the comment section below to ask questions about anything and everything related to these profiles, skills, and traits. Load a copy of the PDF through Google Drive here.

[pdfjs-viewer url=”http%3A%2F%2Fsisypheanhigh.com%2Fmalachite%2Fwp-content%2Fuploads%2F2018%2F09%2FProfiles-Skills-Traits.pdf” viewer_width=100% viewer_height=600px fullscreen=true download=true print=true]

GAP Scoring: March 10, 2017

Your course calendar tells us that we’re a couple of days away from the second GAP score of Q3. As you read this post, especially the GAP protocol, keep in mind that your organizational skill is the concrete on which everything else is built. Make time for all of this, in class and at home, and never lose sight of the purpose of what we do and what you’ve been assigned.

And think about pushing some of your peers to stay focused during the period. Even a day or two of renewed focus is enough to shift the GAP score up a bit, and the alternative…


Clear and Unyielding


As you read the following essay, replace every reference to teaching with a reference to you, your learning, and what it takes to evaluate yourself through grade abatement:

A copy of this will be provided in class, too, to facilitate your reading of it. Take the time to see past the superficial audience — teachers — and into the universal insight on display here. To help, start with the pull quotes from the article. Here they are, with the language altered so that they reference student learning and GAP scoring, not teaching:

You talk enough dirt about yourself and [teachers and peers] will start to believe it.

I’m as guilty as anyone of distorting my [learning]. When talking to [peers and teachers], I often play up the progressive elements.

As an aside, any time you edit the original text of a quotation, use brackets. In this case, it shifts the nouns and pronouns so that you can apply them directly to yourself.

The first of those pull quotes is always a concern: You must avoid downplaying your success, especially when collaboration and collegiality are vital to our work overall. You need to develop confidence, which isn’t quite as difficult as you might think. The second pull quote is part of one of the most important paragraphs, because it deals with a more common problem: ducking the ugly truths about our own progress. Here it is with the language altered again:

I’m as guilty as anyone of distorting my [learning]. When talking to [peers and teachers], I often play up the progressive elements: Student-led discussions. Creative projects. Guided discovery activities. I mumble through the minor, inconvenient fact that my [learning] is, at its core, deeply traditional. I let my walk and my talk drift apart. Not only does this thwart other [peers and teachers] in their attempts to honestly evaluate my approach, but it blocks my own self-evaluation. I can’t grow properly unless I see my own work with eyes that are sympathetic, but clear and unyielding.

The bolded sentence is critical. This is where you all are, two-thirds of the way through the third quarter of the year: in need of “eyes that are sympathetic, but clear and unyielding.” If, at its core, your learning remains deeply traditional, you must account for that.

Start here: What does traditional learning look like in your life? To what extent do you “play up the progressive elements” of your learning, especially during GAP scoring? To what extent is the core of your progress “deeply traditional,” and how can you remove that obstruction?

Answer these questions in conversation and in writing. Focus on insight. Then use that insight to inform the GAP scoring assignment outlined below.


GAP Scoring: March 10, 2017


First, though, let’s test your self-control, close reading, and self-awareness. Do not complete this form until Friday during your class period:

Again, do not complete that until Friday, March 10. Don’t complete it in its embedded form, and don’t complete it through Google Classroom. You still have two days to generate evidence for your GAP score. You have another post assigned to your class that deals with your recent writing work, a reboot of your Pareto Projects, and plenty of good and bad decisions made during those all-important 39 minutes. Give yourself 48 hours or so to read these instructions, work through recent posts, and think critically about your progress.

You should also use your newly strengthened organization to revisit the updated guide/overview of grade abatement, which will recalibrate you before you tackle one of these GAP forms:

Grade Abatement Triptychs

Even some of the students who have earned a GAP 9 in the past have lapsed over the last three weeks, which was always a possibility when we moved to shorter time frame. Each bad decision is magnified. By the same logic, all of your good work is magnified, too. Look carefully at the profiles and even more carefully at the protocol, which has been updated slightly in order to clarify how to apply it to your body of work. As always, you must focus only on the evidence you’ve generated.

Ask questions about these instructions in class and in the comment section below, and remember: You are balancing many assignments right in order to test your organization and advocacy. If you feel overwhelmed, advocate for yourself. If you are confused, keep attacking the work, alone and with peers, until it makes sense. If you feel frustrated, find someone who knows how to listen, vent, and then fix the problem.